19 September 2008

  • Health Sect'y Does End Run to Block Women's Healthcare Options

    We're heading to Cha-Am in an hour or two, but I was so concerned about this information that I felt it needed to be shared, especially because the clock is ticking, as far as being able to take action.

    Last month, Health and Human Services Secretary Mike Leavitt issued a regulation that would ostensibly protect health care providers from discrimination.  Sounds like a good measure, no?  But looking into the substance of his regulation shows that it is actually a cover for removing patients' access to not only treatment but informaiton about treatment options.  Most importantly, it will affect women's reproductive rights.

    Here's the next of an op-ed piece in Thursday's New York Times, written by Hillary Clinton and Cecile Richards, president of Planned Parenthood.

    LAST month, the Bush administration launched the latest salvo in its eight-year campaign to undermine women’s rights and women’s health by placing ideology ahead of science: a proposed rule from the Department of Health and Human Services that would govern family planning. It would require that any health care entity that receives federal financing — whether it’s a physician in private practice, a hospital or a state government — certify in writing that none of its employees are required to assist in any way with medical services they find objectionable.

    Laws that have been on the books for some 30 years already allow doctors to refuse to perform abortions. The new rule would go further, ensuring that all employees and volunteers for health care entities can refuse to aid in providing any treatment they object to, which could include not only abortion and sterilization but also contraception.

    Health and Human Services estimates that the rule, which would affect nearly 600,000 hospitals, clinics and other health care providers, would cost $44.5 million a year to administer. Astonishingly, the department does not even address the real cost to patients who might be refused access to these critical services. Women patients, who look to their health care providers as an unbiased source of medical information, might not even know they were being deprived of advice about their options or denied access to care.

    The definition of abortion in the proposed rule is left open to interpretation. An earlier draft included a medically inaccurate definition that included commonly prescribed forms of contraception like birth control pills, IUD’s and emergency contraception. That language has been removed, but because the current version includes no definition at all, individual health care providers could decide on their own that birth control is the same as abortion.

    The rule would also allow providers to refuse to participate in unspecified “other medical procedures” that contradict their religious beliefs or moral convictions. This, too, could be interpreted as a free pass to deny access to contraception.

    Many circumstances unrelated to reproductive health could also fall under the umbrella of “other medical procedures.” Could physicians object to helping patients whose sexual orientation they find objectionable? Could a receptionist refuse to book an appointment for an H.I.V. test? What about an emergency room doctor who wishes to deny emergency contraception to a rape victim? Or a pharmacist who prefers not to refill a birth control prescription?

    The Bush administration argues that the rule is designed to protect a provider’s conscience. But where are the protections for patients?

    The 30-day comment period on the proposed rule runs until Sept. 25. Everyone who believes that women should have full access to medical care should make their voices heard. Basic, quality care for millions of women is at stake.

     

    Some additional information:

    • There are already three laws on the books that specifically provide protections to shield healthcare providers from providing services they find morally repugnant.  
    • The Department of Health and Human Services has provided no documented cases of discrimination against a healthcare provider, so it is unclear where the need for this regulation lies.
    • There is an article about a letter circulating in the Houes of Representatives, providing additional arguments against the regulation.
    • There is additional analysis from the Our Bodies, Ourselves website.
    • Original Helath & Human Services news release is here.  The full text of the regulation is here.

    The thirty-day public comment period for this regulation expires September 25.  Your voice is needed to prevent this regulation from being enacted.  You can provide that feedback through pages set up by two resources: the American Civil Liberties Union and Planned Parenthood.  Please take a minute to send your comments.

     

Comments (12)

  • Yes! Spread the word.

  • Done.

    Does this not sound dictatorial? How are we different from other countries, where the population was dictated to about birth control?

  • Wow, scary.  Thanks for bringing this to my attention.

  • Scary shit.

  • sorry, have to disagree here. not a fan of govt dictating what one ought to do. it may be something that you agree with this time, but you give the govt too much power, how knows what's next.

  • thanks for the info. i have done my part.

  • I always find you chock full of important news, political and personal. Thanks for spreading the word.
    Hope you enjoy your trip to Cha-am!

  • Thank you so much for posting this. I'm really glad you brought this to my attention. I spread the word...hopefully majority of my friends will leave comments.

  • Ouch. This could lead us into some scary territory.

    I don't know, shouldn't we make Doctors and other medical staff take an oath to adhere to the Hippocratic oath of "to help, or at least to do no harm," and "help" and "harm" should be defined from the patient's point of view. I know that's already a guiding principle, but maybe we should beef it up. This regulation is basically allowing a medical professional to refuse to do any service that benefits someone with whom they disagree from a moral (personal) standpoint. This could totally result in harm to the patient.

  • @generasianx - Tony, it might be a matter of perspective, but I see the proposed regulation as being government dictation, not the removal of it.  The legislative and judicial branches have written and upheld the laws about the relationship between the patient and the health care provider. 

    In this case, the executive branch is bypassing the two other branches of government and is dictating that a health care provider can withhold information about treatment options from a patient.  I say "dictating" because the executive branch is responsible for executing the laws that the legislative branch writes and the judiciary upholds, not dictating their own versions of laws.

  • @Paradise_Lady - @Mabel - @coletteatsea - @Celestial_Rose2002 - @ZSA_MD - Thanks for doing your part and getting the word out.  The Bush administration's willingness to abuse the balance of power between the three branches of government and to legislate by executive order and departmental regulation is yet another example of the extent to which the Constitution has suffered the past seven years.

  • Scary stuff.  WE HAVE TO ELECT OBAMA-BIDEN!!!

Comments are closed.

Post a Comment